In recent weeks, the Conficker virus has been causing a lot of havoc everywhere – account lockouts, network congestion and a lot of headaches. People running Symantec anti-virus software know the same virus as “Downadup”, and that’s not the 1st time a Virus gets labeled differently by different companies. After all, there’s no single authority that investigates viruses, but that got me thinking – maybe it’s time we had one.
With things as they are now, it takes the anti-virus market some time to react to new viruses. Each AV vendor gets samples from its customers, analyzes them and issues signature updates to its product. Each vendor uses its own methodology to assign a priority, and as a result, some vendors take longer to react. In the Conficker case, for example, Symantec’s product is still unable to remove the infection today, almost 3 months since the virus’s first appearance. Even when an update is issued, it’s usually available only for customers of AV vendors, while users with AV software are stranded (We’ll discuss the stupidity of not having AV software on your computer another time).
When a new type of virus or disease appears in the real world, no one waits for Pfizer or Bayer to classify it and inform the public. In the USA, we have the Department of Health and Human Services and the CDC (Center for Disease Control), as well as other federal agencies like FEMA to help manage outbreaks. Since computer worms and viruses do have an economic impact, which could easily reach disastrous proportions (like in the case of worms such as MS Blaster, Code-Red and Sasser), I feel that this sort of thing should definitely be at-least shared by the governments of the world. A Federal Malware Research Center could bring some order to this wild field, and have the necessary resources to inform the public of new threats and how to manage them.
And another thing, while we're at it...we should stop giving worms "cool" and distinctive names. Maybe if the latest virus was called "The Dumbass 1", virus writers were a little less proud of themselves. Now seriously, a malware's name is not a big deal, but it's sad to say that the press today is still glorifying viruses, thereby encouraging low-self-esteemed jerks to write them. Writing a virus is stupid and detestable, and this message should be delivered clearly whenever the issue is discussed in the media - no discounts or exceptions.
Wednesday, January 28, 2009
Monday, January 19, 2009
Never take candy from strangers
Yesterday, my darling wife told me that she got a weird SMS about 9.99$ and she's not sure what it is. Turned out it was from some IQ-Test she took online on FaceBook. When she completed the test, she was asked for her phone, to which her score was sent, along with the message that she just subscribed to a 9.99$ a month service. Clearly, this is a scam, but my sweetheart never thought that something from such a reputable source like FaceBook could be harmful.
"This is exactly how the 1st nasty Viruses/worms started to spread", I told her. A worm would harvest his victims address book, and send itself to all of his recipients. The guy's poor friends and family members would think that this, coming from a friend or family member, must be legit, but of course, it wasn't. Later on, some worms got even cleverer, and spoofed the source address to be someone else from the list, so that the victims could not know who of their close-ones is really the source of the infection.
Luckily, some people have learned to beware of wolves in sheep's clothing, and others are protected by more secure software that wouldn't let them open attachments, but the success of that "service" and others like it shows that apparently, many people still fall for that old trick. Well, if you, or your close ones think that since FaceBook is a legitimate site, then everything on it is too, think again. Pretty much anybody can upload data to FaceBook or write an app for it, and although the site has a lot of security features, it's far from secure. This specific application gives you an IQ test comprised of 10 questions (I won't waste your time with explaining why such a test is closer to guessing your IQ that actually measuring it) and asks for your phone number. To that phone, it sends a confirmation code that you need to punch in to the website, which then sends you an SMS with your so-called IQ. By entering the code, you are actually agreeing to be subscribed to a service that charges 10$ a month. Although this is written both on the website and on the SMS message, some people might miss that, or misunderstand it. Many wouldn't notice another 10$ charge on their cell service bill, and some people are making millions on those people's back.
This type of story shows why information security is more about security than information. Although this is propagated by computers, it could just as easily be done via just the phone, through an interactive TV channel, and many others. Even if you don't like computers, or maybe ESPECIALLY if you don't like computers, this poses a real risk. Not only can you be billed, you can never know for sure where your info will end up in. Maybe tomorrow you'll be flooded with 20 SMSs a day, advertizing the current Viagra or Rolex, or maybe be part of an identity theft operation. The most important lesson here is this: FaceBook is NOT your friend, and neither are MySpace or any other web service. Always assume the worst about an information source, even if you've used it for years and it was great otherwise. The bad guys, or "evil doers" as W likes to call them, are all around, and they will keep on finding new ways to separate us and our money. Just make sure it's not you, and I might also suggest educating your friends and loved ones too.
"This is exactly how the 1st nasty Viruses/worms started to spread", I told her. A worm would harvest his victims address book, and send itself to all of his recipients. The guy's poor friends and family members would think that this, coming from a friend or family member, must be legit, but of course, it wasn't. Later on, some worms got even cleverer, and spoofed the source address to be someone else from the list, so that the victims could not know who of their close-ones is really the source of the infection.
Luckily, some people have learned to beware of wolves in sheep's clothing, and others are protected by more secure software that wouldn't let them open attachments, but the success of that "service" and others like it shows that apparently, many people still fall for that old trick. Well, if you, or your close ones think that since FaceBook is a legitimate site, then everything on it is too, think again. Pretty much anybody can upload data to FaceBook or write an app for it, and although the site has a lot of security features, it's far from secure. This specific application gives you an IQ test comprised of 10 questions (I won't waste your time with explaining why such a test is closer to guessing your IQ that actually measuring it) and asks for your phone number. To that phone, it sends a confirmation code that you need to punch in to the website, which then sends you an SMS with your so-called IQ. By entering the code, you are actually agreeing to be subscribed to a service that charges 10$ a month. Although this is written both on the website and on the SMS message, some people might miss that, or misunderstand it. Many wouldn't notice another 10$ charge on their cell service bill, and some people are making millions on those people's back.
This type of story shows why information security is more about security than information. Although this is propagated by computers, it could just as easily be done via just the phone, through an interactive TV channel, and many others. Even if you don't like computers, or maybe ESPECIALLY if you don't like computers, this poses a real risk. Not only can you be billed, you can never know for sure where your info will end up in. Maybe tomorrow you'll be flooded with 20 SMSs a day, advertizing the current Viagra or Rolex, or maybe be part of an identity theft operation. The most important lesson here is this: FaceBook is NOT your friend, and neither are MySpace or any other web service. Always assume the worst about an information source, even if you've used it for years and it was great otherwise. The bad guys, or "evil doers" as W likes to call them, are all around, and they will keep on finding new ways to separate us and our money. Just make sure it's not you, and I might also suggest educating your friends and loved ones too.
Monday, January 12, 2009
The human factor
Many companies base a significant part of their manpower on outsourced workers, and this is an effective way to conveniently manage human resources that enabled financial efficiency in most cases. An aspect that many managers tend to forget is the issue of security. Are outsourced workers a source of danger to the company?
This post will anger many readers, I’m sure. After all, millions of people make an honest living as outsourced workers and many companies depend on them. However, the truth must be told, even if unpleasant. Outsourced workers could be a major security threat for the organization in many cases, and history records quite a few cases of serious damage suffered by companies that didn’t take the appropriate measures. No, I’m not saying outsourced workers are treacherous, bad or dangerous. In many cases this is exactly the opposite, because employees whose position is not secured as full-time employees will often outperform others to demonstrate their worthiness. However, the outsourcing model causes workers, esp. in the maintenance field, to be exposed to certain risks.
One problem stems from the fact that outsourced workers usually make a lot less money than FTEs. The economic pressure causes these employees to be an easy target for industrial espionage. For example, a known case involved a cleaner who was offered a significant amount in return for a daily visit to the floor-printers of his organization, and collecting the printed matter that was left there by other employees. These print-outs are of random content, but frequently include sensitive material, such as email correspondence, financial reports, future-product info etc. Such a random collection could be extremely valuable for hostile parties, both for industrial espionage and infrastructure penetration. The sum that was offered to that employee was larger than his monthly salary, and you’d be hard-pressed to find people who make 2000$ a month and can resist such a temptation. For some of them, this is a unique opportunity to finally get out of debt.
Another problem is that managers often ignore outsourced workers when thinking about their employees, and these workers are often excluded from routine activities. Often they don’t receive email that is sent to other employees (if they even have an account) or invited to events and lectures with the rest of the company. These employees might miss the companies’ procedures about information security, simply because these were never given to them in an orderly fashion. This is less obvious for technical staff, but in case of the cleaning crew, administration etc – these people are usually with the company for short periods and often do not receive thorough guidance about the procedures and guidelines. An FTE, for example, is often assigned a mentor or “buddy” for a while, who helps him get acquainted and learn what is permissible and what is not. A cleaner or security guard, on the other hand, often finds himself alone, trying to distinguish right from wrong by randomly asking co-workers or guessing. Such an employee might think that using another’s computer for surfing the web is a reasonable thing to do, just like making a phone call from someone’s phone is legitimate and common. In most companies, a phone call costs money, but is not dangerous. Web surfing, on the other hand, could introduce spyware or a virus to the computer, and that is less pleasant.
It’s important to stress once again that the purpose of this is not to impeach all outsourced workers, but to stress the great importance of them to the “system”. This requires that they be treated as equals. Even a temporary and low-ranking worker must receive a detailed guide, including the nuances of working at the company, and stressing the aspects of information security and security policies. Besides clarifying the importance of protecting the company values, such sharing of information could strengthen the bond between the employee and the employer, and reduce the temptation to cross the lines. Let’s not forget, by the way, the full timers could cross the same lines and there are many recorded incidents where even high-ranking officials succumbed to external pressure, or simply prepared a nest for a rainy day. This leads to one conclusion – there is no alternative to professional risk management procedures, which include identifying risk sources and plugging holes on a personal and systematic level.
This post will anger many readers, I’m sure. After all, millions of people make an honest living as outsourced workers and many companies depend on them. However, the truth must be told, even if unpleasant. Outsourced workers could be a major security threat for the organization in many cases, and history records quite a few cases of serious damage suffered by companies that didn’t take the appropriate measures. No, I’m not saying outsourced workers are treacherous, bad or dangerous. In many cases this is exactly the opposite, because employees whose position is not secured as full-time employees will often outperform others to demonstrate their worthiness. However, the outsourcing model causes workers, esp. in the maintenance field, to be exposed to certain risks.
One problem stems from the fact that outsourced workers usually make a lot less money than FTEs. The economic pressure causes these employees to be an easy target for industrial espionage. For example, a known case involved a cleaner who was offered a significant amount in return for a daily visit to the floor-printers of his organization, and collecting the printed matter that was left there by other employees. These print-outs are of random content, but frequently include sensitive material, such as email correspondence, financial reports, future-product info etc. Such a random collection could be extremely valuable for hostile parties, both for industrial espionage and infrastructure penetration. The sum that was offered to that employee was larger than his monthly salary, and you’d be hard-pressed to find people who make 2000$ a month and can resist such a temptation. For some of them, this is a unique opportunity to finally get out of debt.
Another problem is that managers often ignore outsourced workers when thinking about their employees, and these workers are often excluded from routine activities. Often they don’t receive email that is sent to other employees (if they even have an account) or invited to events and lectures with the rest of the company. These employees might miss the companies’ procedures about information security, simply because these were never given to them in an orderly fashion. This is less obvious for technical staff, but in case of the cleaning crew, administration etc – these people are usually with the company for short periods and often do not receive thorough guidance about the procedures and guidelines. An FTE, for example, is often assigned a mentor or “buddy” for a while, who helps him get acquainted and learn what is permissible and what is not. A cleaner or security guard, on the other hand, often finds himself alone, trying to distinguish right from wrong by randomly asking co-workers or guessing. Such an employee might think that using another’s computer for surfing the web is a reasonable thing to do, just like making a phone call from someone’s phone is legitimate and common. In most companies, a phone call costs money, but is not dangerous. Web surfing, on the other hand, could introduce spyware or a virus to the computer, and that is less pleasant.
It’s important to stress once again that the purpose of this is not to impeach all outsourced workers, but to stress the great importance of them to the “system”. This requires that they be treated as equals. Even a temporary and low-ranking worker must receive a detailed guide, including the nuances of working at the company, and stressing the aspects of information security and security policies. Besides clarifying the importance of protecting the company values, such sharing of information could strengthen the bond between the employee and the employer, and reduce the temptation to cross the lines. Let’s not forget, by the way, the full timers could cross the same lines and there are many recorded incidents where even high-ranking officials succumbed to external pressure, or simply prepared a nest for a rainy day. This leads to one conclusion – there is no alternative to professional risk management procedures, which include identifying risk sources and plugging holes on a personal and systematic level.
Friday, January 2, 2009
Is it safe? Not if you're Jewish!
The fighting in Israel in the past days is having an impact on the cyber world as well. This time, two major Israeli sites - Ynet and Discount Bank have been defaced.
When the fighting between Israel and this-or-that Arab faction breaks out, as happens once every few months, national hackers from around the globe have an excuse to waging some cyber war. This time, a group of Morrocan hackers called "Team Evil" has mounted a successful attack against two major Israeli sites. The two sites are the site belonging to Discount Bank, one of Israel's largest banks, and the other is the English version of YNet, Israel's 2nd largest web portal, operated by Yedioth Aharonot, Israel's largest daily newspaper.
The defacement shows some graphic images of dead terrorists, accompanied by anti-Israeli text. At 1st, this was thought to be a simple deface, but turns out the hackers actually brute-forced the passwords to the accounts of the sites on the Israeli hosting provider and domain registrar DomainTheNet. this allowed the hackers to impersonate the account holders and modify the DNS records to point to another website, without ever actually penetrating the original website.
This sort of attack is much easier than cracking the original websites, which are very secure, but ironically, harder to resolve. DNS modifications take time to propagate throughout the world - as long as 48 hours, so it took quite a while until the hack got noticed. When it was fixed, again, it takes a while to propagate so currently, quite a lot of users will still get the defaced page and might continue to be affected for over a day.
This breach illustrates the importance of creating a complete security policy. A company can invest millions in securing it's web farm, but a minor overlooked password could lead to an effective attack. The lesson is simple - when securing a resource, we must take into consideration every aspect of its security. In this case, the person who created the domain account with DomainTheNet simply chose an insecure password (which is a secondary lesson in this case) but there are other, simpler ways to bypass security. For example, making changes to a domain directly with ISOC, Israel's Internet Society and main registrar involves submitting a request via a web form, and then completing the request by sending a fax. The web form has virtually no security, and forging a fax of this nature is also pretty easy. Another example: Many companies rely on Email a primary, or even the only way to communicate with customers. Hacking a user's mail account is usually pretty easy, either by using brute force or calling the ISP and resetting the password, and once you have someone's email, you can use that to reset passwords of most other accounts that the user has. In short, there's an old expression to keep in mind: The chain is only as strong as its weakest link!
When the fighting between Israel and this-or-that Arab faction breaks out, as happens once every few months, national hackers from around the globe have an excuse to waging some cyber war. This time, a group of Morrocan hackers called "Team Evil" has mounted a successful attack against two major Israeli sites. The two sites are the site belonging to Discount Bank, one of Israel's largest banks, and the other is the English version of YNet, Israel's 2nd largest web portal, operated by Yedioth Aharonot, Israel's largest daily newspaper.
The defacement shows some graphic images of dead terrorists, accompanied by anti-Israeli text. At 1st, this was thought to be a simple deface, but turns out the hackers actually brute-forced the passwords to the accounts of the sites on the Israeli hosting provider and domain registrar DomainTheNet. this allowed the hackers to impersonate the account holders and modify the DNS records to point to another website, without ever actually penetrating the original website.
This sort of attack is much easier than cracking the original websites, which are very secure, but ironically, harder to resolve. DNS modifications take time to propagate throughout the world - as long as 48 hours, so it took quite a while until the hack got noticed. When it was fixed, again, it takes a while to propagate so currently, quite a lot of users will still get the defaced page and might continue to be affected for over a day.
This breach illustrates the importance of creating a complete security policy. A company can invest millions in securing it's web farm, but a minor overlooked password could lead to an effective attack. The lesson is simple - when securing a resource, we must take into consideration every aspect of its security. In this case, the person who created the domain account with DomainTheNet simply chose an insecure password (which is a secondary lesson in this case) but there are other, simpler ways to bypass security. For example, making changes to a domain directly with ISOC, Israel's Internet Society and main registrar involves submitting a request via a web form, and then completing the request by sending a fax. The web form has virtually no security, and forging a fax of this nature is also pretty easy. Another example: Many companies rely on Email a primary, or even the only way to communicate with customers. Hacking a user's mail account is usually pretty easy, either by using brute force or calling the ISP and resetting the password, and once you have someone's email, you can use that to reset passwords of most other accounts that the user has. In short, there's an old expression to keep in mind: The chain is only as strong as its weakest link!
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
Unleash the hounds!
Most security people are concerned with their current firewall or SSL-VPN, but some are already thinking about the future. We all know that the current line of security products are very secure, and we already have solutions for most current threats, but it's a cat-and-mouse game. We put up firewalls, and the hackers turn their attention to our Dial-up banks. We implement call-back, and they go after the VPN cluster. We get digital certificates and they start targeting our endpoints with Trojans. This is never going to end, of course, but the question is...what's next?
As long as there is money and computers in the world, there will be cyber criminals looking for ways to get them. The question of what threats and exploits are on the horizon is being asked not only by security professionals, but also by software development companies. The 1st company to predict the next threat will possibly the first to develop a solution for it, and capitalize on it when everybody rushes to buy it. So, how do you find the winning horse?
The major shift in the security industry lately was from network security to endpoint security. As security products for the network and the backbone have matured, attackers turned to exploiting the weakness of the human nature. Trojans and spyware became a global phenomenon, opening a channel for direct access to the corporate network through any desktop. Security companies quickly developed a slew of solutions - Anti spyware scanners, Endpoint lockdown mechanisms and Network Access Control systems. By now, most companies have implemented at least some of these, but there are more threats on the horizon.
Criminals are drawn to where the money is, and in the technology world, the money is where the DATA is. While the data in your servers and workstation is probably protected well enough, there are still some sources of data that are less protected. The 1st threat, as I see it, are mobile devices. Pretty much every phone in the world today can do everything a computer can - it can hold contacts, schedules, email and files, and often quite a lot of those. Usually, money can't be stolen directly off your phone, but the personal data can be easily used for identity theft, which can be used to hack the corporate network of your company. Imagine the phone of a company's IT manager being stolen...a list of vendors the company works with can be easily compiled, orders of hardware can be diverted, and passwords can be socially-engineered. If an attacker knows when your IT manager is on vacation or in long meetings, these timetables can be used to coordinate a focused attack. All this is not new, and Security solutions for phones are already quite advanced. Some solutions encrypt the phone's internal memory, so it can't be accessed without a password. Other solutions lock out the phone or format it when given a remote command through the carrier's network. There are, of course, quite a few anti malware products as well. One thing no one is doing yet is a way to prevent the phone from being lost. Cabs, airports, coffee shops - all are prime locations for forgetting your phone, and most are never recovered. Technologies such as RFID can be used to prevent this sort of loss, but it still doesn't have significant adopters.
Another abundant data mine is home networks. Securing a wireless home network isn't hard, but many people are still afraid to mess-around with their router's settings and just leave it open. Some people are concerned about sharing their bandwidth with driver-byers, but the real danger is that an unwanted guest might have unlimited access to your computers. Even if you setup a password on your computer, an attacker has all the time in the world to brute-force it, and it's likely that the average user won't check his event log and notice the failed attempts. Securing the home network is not that hard, really, but apparently, most people don't bother. Very few companies enforce a policy to prevent or control how their employees connect the company laptop to the home network, not to mention storing business files on the home PC. An ideal solution would be for the company to give its employees desktops, which would allow the company full control over what goes on inside it.
Buy every employee a PC, on the company dime? Am I crazy? Well, it will cost a pretty penny, but consider the costs for a minute. This could amount to several hundred dollars per year per employee, but would still be only a negligible part of the cost of an employee to the company. If it would prevent even a single attack, it could be well worth it. I'm not very optimistic that many companies will adopt this idea, but what should definitely happen is an improvement to home network security and cellular phone technologies. Instead of confusing dialog boxes about TKIP, AES, WEP, WPA and Hex Keys, a home router should be secure by default, and easy to configure. For example, a router could be pre-set to generate a random password and display it on a small LCD. The user will be asked to type it into his machines when connecting for the 1st time. Same goes for phones. Phones today are like Windows 3.11. You have to really try to set a lock on it. I think that settings a strong password should be the default action when getting it from the carrier, and only users who really want to and have the know-how can bypass it. No doubt it will be annoying to many, but so is locking your home every time you leave...and yet we are all OK with that! Currently, all router producers focus on performance and price, and I've yet to see even one that boasts better security. Same for phones - it's all about the music and easy texting, but not a single device that is safer. Will we ever learn?
As long as there is money and computers in the world, there will be cyber criminals looking for ways to get them. The question of what threats and exploits are on the horizon is being asked not only by security professionals, but also by software development companies. The 1st company to predict the next threat will possibly the first to develop a solution for it, and capitalize on it when everybody rushes to buy it. So, how do you find the winning horse?
The major shift in the security industry lately was from network security to endpoint security. As security products for the network and the backbone have matured, attackers turned to exploiting the weakness of the human nature. Trojans and spyware became a global phenomenon, opening a channel for direct access to the corporate network through any desktop. Security companies quickly developed a slew of solutions - Anti spyware scanners, Endpoint lockdown mechanisms and Network Access Control systems. By now, most companies have implemented at least some of these, but there are more threats on the horizon.
Criminals are drawn to where the money is, and in the technology world, the money is where the DATA is. While the data in your servers and workstation is probably protected well enough, there are still some sources of data that are less protected. The 1st threat, as I see it, are mobile devices. Pretty much every phone in the world today can do everything a computer can - it can hold contacts, schedules, email and files, and often quite a lot of those. Usually, money can't be stolen directly off your phone, but the personal data can be easily used for identity theft, which can be used to hack the corporate network of your company. Imagine the phone of a company's IT manager being stolen...a list of vendors the company works with can be easily compiled, orders of hardware can be diverted, and passwords can be socially-engineered. If an attacker knows when your IT manager is on vacation or in long meetings, these timetables can be used to coordinate a focused attack. All this is not new, and Security solutions for phones are already quite advanced. Some solutions encrypt the phone's internal memory, so it can't be accessed without a password. Other solutions lock out the phone or format it when given a remote command through the carrier's network. There are, of course, quite a few anti malware products as well. One thing no one is doing yet is a way to prevent the phone from being lost. Cabs, airports, coffee shops - all are prime locations for forgetting your phone, and most are never recovered. Technologies such as RFID can be used to prevent this sort of loss, but it still doesn't have significant adopters.
Another abundant data mine is home networks. Securing a wireless home network isn't hard, but many people are still afraid to mess-around with their router's settings and just leave it open. Some people are concerned about sharing their bandwidth with driver-byers, but the real danger is that an unwanted guest might have unlimited access to your computers. Even if you setup a password on your computer, an attacker has all the time in the world to brute-force it, and it's likely that the average user won't check his event log and notice the failed attempts. Securing the home network is not that hard, really, but apparently, most people don't bother. Very few companies enforce a policy to prevent or control how their employees connect the company laptop to the home network, not to mention storing business files on the home PC. An ideal solution would be for the company to give its employees desktops, which would allow the company full control over what goes on inside it.
Buy every employee a PC, on the company dime? Am I crazy? Well, it will cost a pretty penny, but consider the costs for a minute. This could amount to several hundred dollars per year per employee, but would still be only a negligible part of the cost of an employee to the company. If it would prevent even a single attack, it could be well worth it. I'm not very optimistic that many companies will adopt this idea, but what should definitely happen is an improvement to home network security and cellular phone technologies. Instead of confusing dialog boxes about TKIP, AES, WEP, WPA and Hex Keys, a home router should be secure by default, and easy to configure. For example, a router could be pre-set to generate a random password and display it on a small LCD. The user will be asked to type it into his machines when connecting for the 1st time. Same goes for phones. Phones today are like Windows 3.11. You have to really try to set a lock on it. I think that settings a strong password should be the default action when getting it from the carrier, and only users who really want to and have the know-how can bypass it. No doubt it will be annoying to many, but so is locking your home every time you leave...and yet we are all OK with that! Currently, all router producers focus on performance and price, and I've yet to see even one that boasts better security. Same for phones - it's all about the music and easy texting, but not a single device that is safer. Will we ever learn?
Labels:
cyber crime,
home networks,
malware,
Phones,
routers
Monday, December 15, 2008
There's no business like the scam business
Just a few days ago, the FTC has finally decided to act against Innovative Marketing, Inc. and ByteHosting Internet Services . These two companies are responsible for many, if not most, technical support calls received by pretty much every company in the world. Their variation of spyware nicknamed "Scareware" sneak in to computers and internet sites, and notify the user that his computer is infected with viruses, urging him to buy an anti-virus from these companies. The "warning" is false mostly, and it is designed and branded to look like a genuine notification from Microsoft or the operating system.
Why did it take the FTC so much time to do something about this menace is beyond me, but the question is this - can the FTC really combat this sort of threat? Despite charging only 40$ for their software, both companies made millions of dollars, and that kind of incentive isn't going to go idle just because of some FTC barking. These companies, just like spammers and other shady or illegal operations have never cowered away from authority. In similar cases, the operators would usually disappear and re-start their operation somewhere else. Sometimes under a new name, and other times in another country. Innovative Marketing already has offices in Ukraine, pretty far from the FTCs grab. In fact, I suspect that there at least a few hundred people reading about this in the media and thinking "Hmmmmm...maybe I should start a business like that?"
The Spam market is a good analogy. We have been fighting spam for years now, and we've tried everything. We've enacted legislation , successfully sued spammers , developed technology to fight it and even raised awareness in the public , but Spam rates haven't decreased significantly. Why? Because as long as there's somebody who will buy it, there will be someone to sell it.
That sounds bleaker than I intended, but are we really going to have to live with these computer annoyances forever? I was never an optimist about human nature, and I'm afraid I can't be one here either. The human race has been battling crime since the dawn of time, and despite some very effective law enforcement and punishment systems, people are still stealing, hurting, killing and more. Bottom line? We shall always rejoice when spammers or other cyber terrorists are taken down, but the hard truth is that this is a fight that's never going to end. Maybe it's time to think of taking out some insurance...
Why did it take the FTC so much time to do something about this menace is beyond me, but the question is this - can the FTC really combat this sort of threat? Despite charging only 40$ for their software, both companies made millions of dollars, and that kind of incentive isn't going to go idle just because of some FTC barking. These companies, just like spammers and other shady or illegal operations have never cowered away from authority. In similar cases, the operators would usually disappear and re-start their operation somewhere else. Sometimes under a new name, and other times in another country. Innovative Marketing already has offices in Ukraine, pretty far from the FTCs grab. In fact, I suspect that there at least a few hundred people reading about this in the media and thinking "Hmmmmm...maybe I should start a business like that?"
The Spam market is a good analogy. We have been fighting spam for years now, and we've tried everything. We've enacted legislation , successfully sued spammers , developed technology to fight it and even raised awareness in the public , but Spam rates haven't decreased significantly. Why? Because as long as there's somebody who will buy it, there will be someone to sell it.
That sounds bleaker than I intended, but are we really going to have to live with these computer annoyances forever? I was never an optimist about human nature, and I'm afraid I can't be one here either. The human race has been battling crime since the dawn of time, and despite some very effective law enforcement and punishment systems, people are still stealing, hurting, killing and more. Bottom line? We shall always rejoice when spammers or other cyber terrorists are taken down, but the hard truth is that this is a fight that's never going to end. Maybe it's time to think of taking out some insurance...
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
The art of war
Although there's nothing nice about war, I'm using the title of Sun Tzu's famous work to raise this point: Is information security a science, or art? According to Ira Winkler of ISAG, it's definitely science, but I beg to differ. Ira raised this issue in a presentation a few months ago, and we debated this issue for a while.
According to Ira, dealing with information security is purely scientific. You learn the technology, tools, techniques and methods of the field. Whether you put that info to good or bad use is another matter, but at the bottom line, it's about knowledge and the ability to apply it.
If you ask me, I believe that hacking, and defending against hackers, is a lot more of an art than you might think. That's not to say it's not a science, but that it's much more than science. No doubt that to be any good at either side, you must learn the ropes. You need to learn your TCP/IP, understand networking, get familiar with tons of products, as well as their strengths and weaknesses, This, however, is just the first part. If you think about it, every major form of art is based on a lot of technical know-how. If you want to paint the new Mona Lisa, you need to learn how to stretch that canvas on the frame (yeah, today you can buy it pre-stretched, but you catch my drift, right?), select your colors, mix them properly, choose the brushes and start painting. To do it right, you should also learn some color theory, use of perspective and composition, the golden ratio etc. It's certainly possible to create a painting without any of those by just using a pencil or crayon and a piece of paper, but in most cases the outcome will be no more pretty, interesting or relevant than guessing someone's "1234" voice mail pin.
Basically, what I'm saying is that any art is based on some sort of technique that needs to be learned and perfected, and that while many people learn the principles of information security very thoroughly, only a handful of them have the skills to transcend the science and make it into art. This goes both for the hackers and crackers, and those who defend their company against them. It doesn't take much to install and configure a firewall, neither does it take much skill to run some well-documented exploit and break into something, but to be able to inventively use the existing technologies to circumvent a security mechanism or build an effective protection against undocumented or yet-unknown attacks is something else.
For example, let's take the well known SAMY worm that has been written by Samy Kamkar. This worm did not cause significant damage to anyone or anything, so it's a good example of a piece of art. MySpace is very well protected from users running most script commands, and so creating this worm took a lot of inventiveness by Kamkar. He spent weeks on weeks developing his code to circumvent all the various mechanisms, often inventing clever ways to sneak commands through the complex filters used by MySpace. Reading the final code (http://web.archive.org/web/20060208182348/namb.la/popular/tech.html) is not easy even for experienced web developers, but it's clearly a piece of digital poetry. A conventional poet would hunt for new metaphors or synonyms to express himself with rhyme and rhythm, similarly to how a worm writer looks for pieces of code that will "work", and that's the difference between the MySpace security team and Kamkar. The security team were just updating the filters occasionally, whenever a new way to sneak-in code was discovered. Similarly, most security managers update their systems or modify their configuration when new patches or attacks are discovered, but a rare few are as active as the hackers, spending their time researching and trying to come up with new better ways to secure their systems. One such guy, who manages security at a bank I once consulted to, was a perfect example. He spent almost no money on security products, and instead wrote mountains of scripts that blocked every attack I was aware of, and also quite a few things that were only theoretically possible back then.
Don't get me wrong - despite my praise for Karmar's work, I don't condone worm writing, and I don't mean to glorify the horrible things done by virus writers. What I am saying, though, is that hackers ARE artists, and to be able to fight back effectively, we need to become at least as artistic, or we'll always be on the defense. Maybe that's one of the reasons so many ex-hackers are making it so well in the security-officer profession? How to transform oneself from a technical expert to an artist is something that I can't tell anyone how to do, but it's certainly possible. Maybe as a first step, the CISSP certification should include some philosophy lessons, or at least a mandatory reading of the Art of War...
According to Ira, dealing with information security is purely scientific. You learn the technology, tools, techniques and methods of the field. Whether you put that info to good or bad use is another matter, but at the bottom line, it's about knowledge and the ability to apply it.
If you ask me, I believe that hacking, and defending against hackers, is a lot more of an art than you might think. That's not to say it's not a science, but that it's much more than science. No doubt that to be any good at either side, you must learn the ropes. You need to learn your TCP/IP, understand networking, get familiar with tons of products, as well as their strengths and weaknesses, This, however, is just the first part. If you think about it, every major form of art is based on a lot of technical know-how. If you want to paint the new Mona Lisa, you need to learn how to stretch that canvas on the frame (yeah, today you can buy it pre-stretched, but you catch my drift, right?), select your colors, mix them properly, choose the brushes and start painting. To do it right, you should also learn some color theory, use of perspective and composition, the golden ratio etc. It's certainly possible to create a painting without any of those by just using a pencil or crayon and a piece of paper, but in most cases the outcome will be no more pretty, interesting or relevant than guessing someone's "1234" voice mail pin.
Basically, what I'm saying is that any art is based on some sort of technique that needs to be learned and perfected, and that while many people learn the principles of information security very thoroughly, only a handful of them have the skills to transcend the science and make it into art. This goes both for the hackers and crackers, and those who defend their company against them. It doesn't take much to install and configure a firewall, neither does it take much skill to run some well-documented exploit and break into something, but to be able to inventively use the existing technologies to circumvent a security mechanism or build an effective protection against undocumented or yet-unknown attacks is something else.
For example, let's take the well known SAMY worm that has been written by Samy Kamkar. This worm did not cause significant damage to anyone or anything, so it's a good example of a piece of art. MySpace is very well protected from users running most script commands, and so creating this worm took a lot of inventiveness by Kamkar. He spent weeks on weeks developing his code to circumvent all the various mechanisms, often inventing clever ways to sneak commands through the complex filters used by MySpace. Reading the final code (http://web.archive.org/web/20060208182348/namb.la/popular/tech.html) is not easy even for experienced web developers, but it's clearly a piece of digital poetry. A conventional poet would hunt for new metaphors or synonyms to express himself with rhyme and rhythm, similarly to how a worm writer looks for pieces of code that will "work", and that's the difference between the MySpace security team and Kamkar. The security team were just updating the filters occasionally, whenever a new way to sneak-in code was discovered. Similarly, most security managers update their systems or modify their configuration when new patches or attacks are discovered, but a rare few are as active as the hackers, spending their time researching and trying to come up with new better ways to secure their systems. One such guy, who manages security at a bank I once consulted to, was a perfect example. He spent almost no money on security products, and instead wrote mountains of scripts that blocked every attack I was aware of, and also quite a few things that were only theoretically possible back then.
Don't get me wrong - despite my praise for Karmar's work, I don't condone worm writing, and I don't mean to glorify the horrible things done by virus writers. What I am saying, though, is that hackers ARE artists, and to be able to fight back effectively, we need to become at least as artistic, or we'll always be on the defense. Maybe that's one of the reasons so many ex-hackers are making it so well in the security-officer profession? How to transform oneself from a technical expert to an artist is something that I can't tell anyone how to do, but it's certainly possible. Maybe as a first step, the CISSP certification should include some philosophy lessons, or at least a mandatory reading of the Art of War...
Labels:
art,
Cybercrime,
networking,
peace,
science,
threats,
War
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
